top of page

Experts Warn Federal Vaccine Decisions Are Undermining America’s Access and Trust

Oct 9, 2025
2 min read

Medical and scientific experts raised concern last week about the trajectory of U.S. federal vaccine policy, telling Congressional staff at PFID’s Capitol Hill briefing that repeated institutional undermining is jeopardizing public trust, innovation, and children's health.


Their concerns focused on recent decisions by federal agencies and the CDC’s newly overhauled Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP). The speakers criticized the groups for failing to uphold the tradition of evidence-based policymaking and recommendations.


Former Rep. Michael Burgess (R-TX), an obstetrician-gynecologist, reflected favorably on America’s "long and proud history" of pacing the world in vaccine science and immunization policy.


“That leadership is built not only on the remarkable science behind the vaccines but on the trusted framework that evaluates evidence, weighs the risks and benefits, and provides guidance to families and physicians," Burgess said. "When those processes lose transparency or independence, confidence falters. Without confidence, even the best vaccines can’t do their job.”


Dr. Jesse Goodman, former chief scientist at the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and director of the Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research (CBER), said the FDA has long observed a culture of commitment to robust, data-driven dialogue.


There would be internal disagreement at times, he said. But scientific consensus and strategic public input always served as a foundation.


Many of these career scientists are still at the FDA, but he’s worried their voices and expertise are no longer utilized as guiding forces.


"The public can feel very assured by the history of the FDA and what it’s done" he said. "But I fear, in a more subtle way perhaps than the CDC, that that's at risk now. If our FDA starts making bizarre and unprecedented decisions, I think groups like the WHO and the European Medicines Agency are going to look at regulatory decisions at the FDA and begin to question them and question the FDA’s status as a world leader.


"If there is anything in government that’s been a gold standard, it’s the FDA as a regulatory agency, and I really would not like to see that undermined.”


ACIP drew pointed criticism from Dr. Tina Tan, a pediatric infectious diseases physician at Northwestern University and president of Infectious Diseases Society of America.

She said the panel no longer inspires trust after the abrupt dismissal and unvetted replacement of all independent experts and working groups this summer.


“The ACIP that is currently in place is filled with members that absolutely lack the qualifications and the expertise for that job," Tan said. "They’re making recommendations that are directly contradicting the best science we have."


She cited ACIP’s recent change to not recommend the measles-mumps-rubella-varicella (MMRV) vaccine for children under 4.


"This is taking away choice from parents because now kids are going to need two separate vaccines: MMR and varicella," Tan said. "A lot of times, that’s going to require two separate doctor appointments. This is going to lead to missed opportunities to vaccinate or very delayed opportunities to vaccinate, and that’s a problem."


With proven childhood protection against hepatitis B and other diseases expected to be under review at future meetings, the speakers warned that any departure from evidence-driven policy risks leaving children unprotected and public confidence in decline, weakening the very tools that save lives.


Click here to watch a recording of the Sept. 23 briefing.

 
 
 

7 Comments


robot
5 days ago

Dr. Tina Tan’s concern about the MMRV vaccine recommendation change highlights how administrative decisions can disrupt practical healthcare delivery, such as requiring multiple visits for separate vaccines. This kind of logistical challenge reminds us how important timing and coordination are—not just in public health, but in creative fields where precise scheduling matters, like producing educational or advocacy videos that explain complex medical topics to the public. In those cases, matching audio length to visual content is crucial, and tools like AI Music Extender can help by extending instrumental tracks or rearranging passages to fit a desired duration without abrupt cuts. While the output depends on the original audio quality, this approach can save time when syncing background music to timed…

Like

hausler1993
Oct 26

A useful detail about the main page is that it presents one entry point for checking tokens across Solana, Ethereum, Base, and BSC rather than requiring separate tools per chain. The claimed 99.9% accuracy figure is best treated as a starting signal, not a guarantee, so pairing it with your own contract reading still makes sense. For a quick orientation to the multi-chain token checks, the overview is compact and easy to scan.

Like

Allen Barry
Allen Barry
Oct 02

That feels like a perfect brainrot merge of politics and science where nobody wins, especially parents who now face extra doctor visits.

Like

Lifehata
Sep 12

Коли хочеться почитати щось нове, можна відкрити цю сторінку. Є теми про стосунки, привітання, побутові питання та різні цікаві напрямки.

Edited
Like

Infosaray
Sep 10

Если нравятся темы, связанные с астрологией, стоит обратить внимание на https://infosaray.com.ua/ru/blog/interesting/znaki-zodiaka/, где собраны статьи о знаках зодиака. Раздел подходит как для быстрого знакомства с темой, так и для более внимательного чтения.

Like
FOOTER BACKGROUND.jpg
WHITE logo.png

About PFID

Partnership to Fight Infectious Disease is a group of patients, providers, community organizations, academic researchers, business and labor groups, and infectious disease experts working to raise awareness of threats posed by infectious disease.

​

PFID is a 501(c)4 not-for-profit organization.

FB.png
Asset 1_2x.png
linkedin.png
youtube.png
instagram-2.png
Connect with PFID

Thank you. Your message has been received.

© Copyright 2020. Partnership to Fight Infectious Disease

bottom of page